My wife wants to go there this summer, and award air tickets are available, so I guess we'll go. From the little I've researched it, it seems kinda expensive/touristy/ritzy. Like Cancun maybe? Any thoughts or suggestions? (It's her turn to pick)
Aruba would not be my first or second choice. I think it is way overdone, too many tourists and expensive to boot. I suggest either Grenada or Tobago on that end of the Caribbean, and the Bahamas Family Islands on the other.